(Back to the main Havamal Analysis
page ) ( Go to the Next Stanza
)
The
discussion and analysis presented after these
translated stanzas is our
opinion. Read the translations for yourself and our analysis, but also seek
out varied sources and come to your own conclusions.
STANZA 11 OF THE
HAVAMAL
Auden and Taylor:
Better gear than good sense A traveler
cannot carry, A more tedious burden than too much drink A
traveler cannot carry,
Bellows:
A better burden | may no man bear For
wanderings wide than wisdom; Worse food for the journey | he
brings not afield Than an over-drinking of ale.
Bray:
A better burden can no man bear on the
way than his mother wit: and no worse provision can he carry
with him than too deep a draught of ale.
Chisholm:
A man bears no better burden, when on the
wilderness ways than great wisdom. One can have no worse
fare, on road or field, than too much ale.
Hollander:
Better burden bearest thou nowise than
shrewd head on they shoulders; but with worser food farest thou
never than an overmuch of mead.
Terry:
If a man takes with him a mind full of
sense he can carry nothing better; nothing is worse to carry
on your way than a head heavy with beer.
Thorpe:
A worse provision on the way he cannot
carry than too much beer-bibbing; so good is not, as it is
said, beer for the sons of men.
Original Old Norse:
Byrği betri ber-at mağur brautu ağ
en sé manvit mikiğ. Vegnest verra vegur-a hann velli ağ
en sé ofdrykkja öls.
DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
OF STANZA 11
Stanza's 10-14 sort of chain together...or
at least build on
each other.
The first two lines of stanza 11 are exactly
the same as the first two lines of Stanza 10. They basically
say that the best thing you could carry with you on a journey is
wisdom. You can't name another provision, resource, item, or burden
to carry than wisdom as you travel along your way. This can be taken
to refer to more than just a trip from point A to point B, of
course. It makes sense that these lines are talking about life's
journey. Our wanderings
through life.
Lines 3 and 4 then contrast ale (beer, mead,
drink...essentially alcohol) with wisdom. If wisdom is the
BEST thing you could take with you on your journey, then
too-much-alcohol is the WORST thing you could take
with you.
It would be interesting to go through the
Havamal, making a tick-mark on a piece of paper everytime certain
topics come up. The Importance of Wisdom. Caution.
Listening. Watching. Remaining Sober.
Family. etc. etc. Some of these topics are all through
the Havamal...over and over, with slight variations. This
only emphasizes the importance of the advice regarding
these topic to
our ancestors.
(
Back
to the main
Havamal Analysis
page ) ( Go to the Next Stanza
)
|