(Back to the main Havamal Analysis
page ) ( Go to the Next Stanza
)
The
discussion and analysis presented after these
translated stanzas is our
opinion. Read the translations for yourself and our analysis, but also seek
out varied sources and come to your own conclusions.
STANZA 12 OF THE
HAVAMAL
Auden and Taylor:
Less good than belief would have it Is
mead for the sons of men: A man knows less the more he drinks,
Becomes a befuddled fool,
Bellows:
Less good there lies | than most
believe In ale for mortal men; For the more he drinks | the
less does man Of his mind the mastery hold.
Bellow's Note: Some editors have
combined this stanza in various ways with the last two lines of
stanza it, as in the manuscript the first two lines of the latter
are abbreviated, and, if they belong there at all, are presumably
identical with the first two lines of stanza
10.
Bray:
Less good than they say for the sons of men
is the drinking oft of ale: for the more they drink, the
less can they think and keep a watch o'er their wits.
Chisholm:
Ale is not so good as they say for the
sons of men. A man’s mind knows less, the more he drinks.
Hollander:
For good it is not, though good it is
thought, mead for the sond sof men; the deeper he drinks the
dimmer grows the mind of many a man.
Terry:
Beer isn't such a blessing to men as it's
supposed to be; the more you swallow, the less you stay the
master of your mind.
Thorpe:
A worse provision no man can take from
table than too much beer-bibbing: for the more he
drinks the less control he has of his own mind.
DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
OF STANZA 12
Stanza's 10-14 sort of chain together...or
at least build on each other. Here, Stanza 12 continues and
expands on the topic of alcohol which was brought up in
Stanza 11.
Lines 1 and 2 suggest that there is this
general belief that the drinking of ale is good for men, but that
this belief is wrong. Basically beer is not the blessing to
men that they believe it
to be.
Lines 3 and 4 explain why. Basically,
the more you drink the less control you have of your own mind and
deeds. Auden and Taylor's translation goes as far as to say
that the more a man drinks, the less he know...and he becomes a
"befuddled fool."
So, we have in Stanza 10-14 this discussion
of the incredible importance of wisdom...and then the poem begins to
take us in the direction of explaining that alcohol
reduces wisdom.
Something that we sometimes forget when
reading the stanzas that refer to alcohol, is that we have many more
drugs and mind-altering substances today than they had in the days
of our ancestors. Today's drugs are more powerful and in many
cases can be even more devestating that alcohol. So, we would
be wise to read these stanzas about alcohol as referring to any
substance that clouds our wisdom...or muddles
our minds.
(
Back
to the main
Havamal Analysis
page ) ( Go to the Next Stanza
)
|